How the scores work

What the candidates do

Every candidate answers the same set of questions. Each question is an issue a councillor might have to face, with four sensible answers to choose from. There is no right or wrong answer.

For each question, the candidate puts the four answers in order, based on their values, from the one they value the most to the one they value the least.

Once they move on to the next question, they cannot go back and change it. This provides integrity to the system.

How answers become scores

Each answer secretly belongs to one of four values: Environment, Economic, Social or Governance. The candidate is not told which is which.

The answer they like most gives its value 3 points. The next gives 2, the next 1 and the last 0.

Where the candidate put the answerPoints to that value
Valued most3
Second2
Third1
Valued least0

Over the whole questionnaire, those points build a score out of 10 for each value.

The four scores are shared out, so nobody can be top at everything: when one value goes up, another comes down. The scores show which values a candidate puts first, not how good a candidate they are and what skills or knowledge they have.

If a candidate has not answered every question, their scores are worked out from the questions they did answer, and their card says how many that was.

How we match candidates to your values

When you put the three values in your order, the site does not just look for the biggest numbers. It compares your order with each candidate's.

  1. You put the three values in order

    That is all you do. You do not get a score.

  2. Every candidate already has an order too

    It comes from their scores on the same three values: their highest score is their first value, their lowest is their last.

  3. We put the two orders side by side

    We look at how closely each candidate's order lines up with yours, value by value. Your top priorities count the most.

  4. The closest matches come first

    The candidates whose order is most like yours go to the top of the page. When two are equally close, the one stronger on your top values comes first.

An example with three made-up candidates

Your order
  1. 1Environment
  2. 2Economic
  3. 3Social

The candidates come out in this order. Each card shows the candidate's three scores, highest first, then their Governance score.

1st

Sally Someone

Scores out of 10: Environment 8.4, Economic 6.3, Social 3.8; skill: Governance 1.5

Same order as you.

2nd

Jane Doe

Scores out of 10: Environment 9.4, Social 3.2, Economic 1.3; skill: Governance 6.2

Environment first, like you. Your second and third are swapped.

3rd

Joe Bloggs

Scores out of 10: Economic 9.3, Environment 6.3, Social 3.8; skill: Governance 0.7

Your top two, swapped: Economic is his strongest value.

Joe Bloggs scores 9.3 on Economic, but he comes third. Economic is his strongest value, and you put Environment first. Jane Doe puts Environment first, as you do, so she comes ahead of him.

Why compare orders, and not just the highest score?

A candidate's four scores are shared out, so a high score on one value always means lower scores on the others. A single score says little on its own; what the scores show is which values a candidate puts first. So we compare their order with yours.

Where is Governance?

Governance is about how a council is run, which every councillor needs to do well, whatever else they put first. So it is not one of the values you put in order. Every candidate's Governance score is shown as a bar of its own, after the three values.

Candidates who have not completed their profile, or whose profile is unclaimed or withdrawn, are listed last in alphabetical order.

What we keep secret

We do not publish which answer belongs to which value. That way nobody can pick answers just to push a score up.

Data sources

Council boundaries and the suburb-to-council lookup use data from the LIST (Land Information System Tasmania). © State of Tasmania (the LIST), used under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia licence (CC BY 3.0). Candidate names come from the Tasmanian Electoral Commission.